I came across this letter to “Dear Margo” from a poly couple:
DEAR MARGO: I am a very happily married woman with a problem: well-intentioned friends and family. My husband and I are polyamorous and not ashamed of it. We have wonderful girlfriends who are special and a part of our family. The problem is that people assume we are on the verge of divorce, etc. Other than an indelicate “Butt out,” is there any way to get them to see that we are really happy and stable? We’ve been married for five years.
— HAPPILY POLY
(For square readers like me who might need a trip to the dictionary, I will save you some time. “Polyamorous” is the name for multiple sexual relationships within marriage — in this case involving both spouses.)
DEAR HAP: You may not be ashamed of it, but you have to know that this arrangement would strike most people as being somewhere between odd and morally wrong, it being quite far from the norm. I am not sure why you felt the need to breeze it around that you and your husband have “wonderful girlfriends.”
Because you have, however, essentially invited people to “butt in,” you are a little bit stuck in terms of asking them to butt out. I guess the only way to prove yourselves happy and stable is for you two to continue to thrive with your, uh, wonderful girlfriends.
— MARGO, BEWILDEREDLY
Dear Margo is flat out wrong right from the beginning in her reply. Polyamory is NOT having multiple sexual relationships within marriage.Polyamory is having more than one relationship,period.Break down the word,Margo. Poly=many. Amory-love. It isn’t just about having sex with multiple partners, it’s about having relationships with multiple partners. Sure, some poly people base their other relationships on sex but usually it’s a bit more involved than just that. Also, marriage doesn’t have to be in the cards for anyone involved. It can be but isn’t always.
Margo goes on to explain that most people are going to think it’s odd,morally wrong and far from the norm. She’s probably correct but she doesn’t mention that it doesn’t seem at all odd to people to lie,cheat and deceive their significant others while they have affairs with others, whether it be a random hook-up or a longtime affair. People expect those sorts of things yet when you start talking about a woman who doesn’t mind that when her boyfriend goes out of town on business that he spends the evening with another woman…and she has dinner with another boyfriend followed by a night of fantastic sex…it’s perceived as being weird and deviant. There’s no one in the dark,being deceived and they may actually even discuss how their week went,sexcapades included.It’s all done on the up and up,with openness and honesty that doesn’t exist in the “normal” realm of cheating.
It’s more “normal” for the boyfriend to go away on business, call his girlfriend from the hotel after some random girl just gave him a blow job and tell her how much he misses her,yadayada….and the girlfriend is on her way out the door to meet the guy she’s been seeing for months unbeknownst to her boyfriend. They exchange “I love yous” and *mwahs* over the phone and go on their merry way in relationships built on lies.
Whether it’s just an open relationship or polyamory, people who chose that as a basis of their relationship just don’t see monogamy as their cup of tea but they’d rather not lie to people they love. There’s nothing morally wrong about approaching non-monagamy in a responsible way where everyone’s needs,emotional and otherwise are cared for.
Really,though….Margo’s ignorance of the situation aside, if I were the one giving Happily Poly the advice, I’d tell her bravo on being lucky enough to find so many wonderful girlfriends (without the unnecessary quotation marks) that she and her husband are both compatible with.That in itself can be a feat. My husband seems to like girls who look like they belong in a Whitesnake video and usually have some raging chemical imbalance that turns them into Psycho Bitches from Hell. I’m not so attracted to that type.
When it comes to friends’ reaction to the poly way of life, you should expect that people aren’t going to just embrace it and say,”Oh,how wonderful for you!”. There are lots of people who add other partners to their lives to spice things up a bit because maybe it’s gotten old or they recognize that their relationships really are crumbling and they want someone waiting on stand-by. Poly relationships are usually very different from those scenarios and in fact, will not work unless the primary relationship is first solid,strong and built on trust. If your primary marriage is a strong one,then don’t worry about what others think. Over time ,as they see that divorce is not eminent and you’ve still successfully balanced the additions of secondary (or more) partners, they’ll get the picture.
Until then,they may think you’re delusional and strange but hey…that’s ok.